Legal Services India - Law Articles is a Treasure House of Legal Knowledge and information, the law resources is an ever growing database of authentic legal information.

» Home
Monday, November 4, 2024

Indian inheritance law and Women in India

Thu, May 3, 18, 10:44, 7 Years ago
star star star star star
5 out of 5 with 2 ratings
comments: 3 - hits: 8736
If a childless widow dies intestate, everything that belongs to her goes to her in­ laws, and that includes all the wealth she acquired in her lifetime through her own efforts.

If a childless widow dies intestate, everything that belongs to her goes to her in­ laws, and that includes all the wealth she acquired in her lifetime through her own efforts. However, if a widower dies in a similar fashion, his property will go only to his parents and family; but, most definitely, not to his wife's parents.

Why the double standard? Well, that is just how it is. This is just one of the many in-built illogical biases in property laws in India and many other countries. For instance, Tanzanian property laws do not allow married women to' transact property without their husbands' permission. Husbands, of course, are not required to seek spousal consent. Take almost any part of the world, any section of society or any population group, juggle statistics any which way you want, the conclusions are the same ­ women are discriminated against when it comes to wealth and property. Women comprise more than 50 per cent of the world's population but they own less than 1 per cent of the world's wealth, says the United Nations. Women do two­ thirds of the world's work but earn only 10 per cent of the income.

There is no dearth of figures to show the raw deal women get when it comes to ownership of property and wealth. And there is no dearth of platitudes and good intentions expressed by the world's tallest leaders and most influential international institutions and organisations.

"Investing in women and girls has a multiplier effect on productivity and sustained economic growth. Investing in women is not only the right thing to do. It is the smart thing to do," Ban Ki Moon, the secretary-general of the United Nations, had said. The World Bank too calls investing in women "smart economics" because research shows economic growth for women has a valuable multiplier effect. Women are more likely to share their economic gains with their families and communities at large.

Moreover, women's equal rights to land, housing and property are also human rights, recognized in various international human rights instruments. Yet, laws and social customs, and most crucially practices, continue to be skewed against women getting their fair share of wealth.

In India, during the debate on the Hindu Code Bill in Parliament, a majority of the legislators, all men, took a stand against daughters inheriting property from their natal families. Thus, the Hindu Succession Act (HSA) of 1956 did not allow women the right to ancestral property. It was amended as late as 2005 to give daughters equal rights.

In India, there are three sources of land-ownership for women - land transferred from the government, from the market, and through family inheritance. However, inheritance is the
most significant because 87 percent of land is privately owned and hence the amendment is of great importance.

The HSA applies to Sikhs, Buddhists and Jains, but the Christians have their own code and the Muslims have theirs. Then there are the tribal communities of various states whose property rights are governed by their customs and norms. To complicate the issue even further states are allowed to enact their own succession laws. A woman's property rights vary depending on her religion, her marital status, the state she comes from and her tribal identity.

All these variations mean that there is no single set of laws that governs the rights of an Indian woman to property. However what unifies all these various laws is their immunity from constitutional protection against bias and inequality.

. "The amendment to give women equal rights in family property was significant especially as it covers over 80 per cent of the population. Many women have filed cases seeking their share under this amended law and such cases are being heard in courts across the country. However, the number is still small because most women hesitate to ask for their share in property they are afraid of spoiling their relationship with their families," says Kirti Singh, legal convenor of the All India Democratic Women's Association.

The reality revealed by the 2000-01 agricultural census is that of almost 120 mil lion landholders, nearly 13 million, or a mere 11 percent, are women. This is a trend seen across the world. AIthough women farmers are responsible for 60-80 per cent of the food production in developing countries, they are barred from inheriting or owning those fields. It is widely accepted that landlessness is one of the best predictors for poverty around the world. Significantly, of the 1.4 billion people living on less than one dollar a day, 70 per cent are women and girls.

Research and studies across the world have shown the benefits of women gaining secure rights to land and property:  an increase in women's participation in household decision-making, an increase in net household income, a reduction in domestic violence, an in­ creased ability to prevent be­ ing infected by HIV and increased expenditures on food and education for children. Closer home, in Kerala, 49 per cent of women with no property reported physical violence compared to the 7 per cent of women who did own property. This clearly demonstrates the empowerment that property ownership can bestow.

In India, as in many parts of the world, the government has initiated several steps to promote property owner­ ship by women. But little has changed on the ground. For instance, about three decades ago, the Sixth Plan had recommended that states give joint titles to husband and wife in transfer of assets like land and house sites through government programmes. But there is hardly any effort to actually implement this.

The government has also reduced the property registration fee for property owned by a woman, just 6 per cent, compared to the 8 per cent a man has to cough up. The idea was to en­ courage more registrations in the name of women:
The amendment to the HSA too was meant to ensure that women and men became equal heirs to ancestral prop­ erty. Though these measure~ have encouraged some mar­ ginal difference in property ownership, the scenario re­ mains largely unchanged as women are yet to assert their rights.

However, there is reason to be optimistic. In 1993, when 33 per cent of seats in panchayats were reserved for women through a constitutional amendment, people scoffed at the idea. Merely changing the law, they said, could never change conservative mindsets in rural areas. "Initially, we saw out­ right skepticism. Then there was the widely reported phenomenon of 'panchpati' where the actual woman pan­ chayat member's husband conducted business in her name. This still happens in many areas, out today in hundreds of villages, women sarpanch are taking charge. Even women contesting unreserved seats has become acceptable.

Almost 17 years after the law came into force, it is becoming a resounding success in parts of India where you couldn't imagine a woman stepping out of her house let alone conducting the business of an entire village," says Sunder Lal of the Social Centre for Rural Initiative and Advancement (SCRIA) who works in Churu, Rajasthan.

Will men eventually also come around to the idea of sharing family wealth? Per haps they will, but it could require a few more policy and law enforcement nudges' from the government to move women's property rights from paper to practice.

The marumakkatayam system practised among the Nairs of Kerala, the aliya santana observed by the Bunts in Karnataka, and the marumakkal vazhi followed by the Pillais of Tamil Nadu are some of the prominent matrilineal systems of inheriting property in India. Although the Hindu Succession Act of 1956 applies to all Hindus, section 17 of the Act makes some exceptions for these practices. Thus, when a woman who follows the matrilineal custom dies intestate, her property would first devolve upon the children and not the children as well as the husband. Further, heirs of the mother gain precedence over the heirs of the fathers who in turn are given precedence over the heirs of the husband, an order that is inverted in the case of other Hindus.

It must be noted though that all matrilineal systems in India do not follow a standard template. Certain communities have their own practices of inheritance, which are also matrilineal. In the Khasi community of Meghalaya, only the youngest daughter or ka khadduh is eligible to inherit the ancestral property. If she dies without daughter surviving her, her next older sister inherit the ancestral property; and after her, the youngest daughter of that sister. Failing all daughters and their female issues, the property goes back to the mother's sister, mother's . sister's daughter and so on. Among the Garos of Meghalaya, property passes from mother to daughter. Although the sons belong to the mother's ma chong (family), they cannot inherit any portion of the maternal property. Indeed, males, cannot in theory hold any", property other than that acquired through their own exertions. Even this passes on to their children through their. wives (the children's mothers) after marriage.

Variations of such practices can be found in other countries as well. For instance, the Minangkabau ethnic group of West Sumatra, which follows Islam is a matrilineal community.

Among the Nakhis - an ethnic group in the Yunan and Sichuan provinces of China as the heads of the family; the women passed on the inheritance to their children, or to their nephews through their brothers.

Comments

There are no comments for this article.
Only authorized users can leave comments. Please sign in first, or register a free account.
Share
Sponsor
About Author
admin
Member since Feb 20, 2018
Location: India
Following
User not following anyone yet.
You might also like
The law relating to improvements to mortgaged property as embodied under Section 63-A was introduced by the Amending Act of 1929. Before this amendment, the Act, i.e., the Transfer of Property Act, 1882 was silent as to improvements by a mortgagee.
How To Assert A Daughter's Right, Filing A Suit For Partition
Many think that hiring legal counsel would just be an increase in the expenses involved in investing in real estate. If you are of the same opinion, it is time to think again.
A Will or Last Will and Testament is a legal document in the form of a declaration which a person known as a testator will name one or two people or a professional to manage their estate and distribute their estate to named beneficiaries, after their death.
A female Hindu dying intestate without making a Will – the property of the said Hindu goes according to the provisions made in Hindu Succession Act, 1956
A men Hindu passing away intestate without creating a Will
Validity of the Will may be challenged due to Lack of execution
Section 7 of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882 provides that every person competent to contract i.e. a major and of sound mind or is not disqualified by law for contracting.
Perpetuity is an interest, which will not vest till a remote period. One cannot postpone the vesting of the property in the transferee beyond a certain limit. the period for which vesting may be lawfully postponed is called perpetuity period
The non-residents of India can buy property in India. They should be aware of the property registration method in the local region, like Mumbai, Delhi etc.. The sales deed should be verified with the sub-registrar and registrar in the Municipal Corporation. Get along the proofs of identity, residence, PIO/OCI status and other mentioned ones.
While clearly and convincingly holding that possessory title over property cannot be claimed merely on the basis of 'casual possession', the Supreme Court in Poona Ram v. Moti Ram
There is no provision in the Constitution that such an elected representative can claim or ask for a price after he demits office. A claim of this nature reflects as if it is something parasitical.
The Associated Journals Ltd & Anr v. Land & Development Office has clearly and convincingly upheld the eviction order passed against National Herald publisher Associated Journals Limited to vacate ITO premises where Herald House is located.
Property Rights for Married women
Rajesh Yadav Vs State of UP held that the right to shelter is a fundamental right and the State has a Constitutional duty to provide house sites to the poor. Justice Surya Prakash Kesarwani who authored this path breaking judgment observed so while dismissing a PIL seeking eviction of four individuals who allegedly encroached a public land.
Article explains Succession, Testamentary Powers, Intestate Succession/Inheritance, Meaning/Definition of a ‘Will’ and Importance of making a Will.
The outdoor space of our home or the space at the backyard can serve as the area of cooking. However, you should have the basic equipment for grilling food and do up the space elaborately.
Property agents indeed charge high commissions, though the person selling a home pays the amount. However, the seller might pass this cost indirectly to you.
Vineeta Sharma vs Rakesh Sharma held in no uncertain terms that a daughter will have a share after the Hindu Succession (Amendment) Act, 2005, irrespective of whether her father was alive or not at the time of amendment.
It goes without saying that most of us had seen how Roshni scam which is Rs 25,000 crore scam was highlighted extensively some time back in Zee News channel. They termed it as Mission Zameen Jihad.
It is a truly cozier experience to spend a winter evening beside the crackling fire glowing at your backyard fireplace,
Do you have a porch, hot but, or gazebo which you want to cover up with something which can save on your heating bills?
Daulat Singh (D) Thr. Lrs. vs. Rajasthan acceptance of a gift can be inferred by the implied conduct of the donee. Such inference can be ascertained from the surrounding circumstances such as taking into possession the property by the done or by being in the possession of the gift deed itself.
Anup Majee Vs UOI the authority of the CBI to investigate into the allegations in a particular case within Railway areas remain unfettered by the withdrawal of consent of the State Government.
The new Model Tenancy Act offers great benefits to NRIs & landlords to get a sustainable rental income under a disciplined and law-protected environment.
Ahuja Trading Company vs Ramesh Chander Aggarwal that dishonest litigants cannot be allowed to abuse the process of court. This judgment came while hearing a tenancy matter.
The growth in real estate sector has been highlighted through the enactment and guidelines of RERA
KS Narayana Elayathu vs Sandhya Additional District Court, Ernakulam has while making the legal position crystal clear held explicitly that while District Courts are empowered to appoint a guardian for a minor's property, only Family Court can appoint a guardian for the person of a minor.
Smt Durgabala Mandal Vs West Bengal that the daughter-in-law is bound by the undertaking given while obtaining a compassionate appointment to maintain and extend medical assistance to the mother-in-law.
Arunachala Gounder (Dead) Vs Ponnusamy a daughter is capable of inheriting the self-acquired property or share received in the partition of a coparcenary property of her Hindu father dying intestate.
Smt.Sonia Bai vs Bashrath Sahu that under the Hindu Succession Act (amended in 2005), daughters are entitled to get an equal share in their parent’s inherited property.
Ajay Kumar Rathee vs Seema Rathee that the daughter who was aged 20 years of age was not intending to maintain ties with her father. The Court also noted that if that be the case, she can’t claim any amount from him for marriage and education.
Sovakar Guru v. Odisha that entitlement of an employee or an ex-employee to his salary or pension, as the case may be, is an intrinsic part of his right to life under Article 21 and right to property under Article 300A of the Constitution.
Phool Singh vs Amit Kumar that an unregistered agreement to sell, being in contravention of the provisions of the Registration Act, 1908, cannot be accepted by the Court for granting possession in favour of the claimant party.
Arun Kumar Singh v. Smt Jaya Singh that a mere nomination would not confer any beneficial interest on the nominee under an insurance policy and that a nominee is only an authorized hand to receive the insurance amount, which is subject to disbursement amongst the legal heirs under the law of succession governing the parties.
West Bengal v/s Dilip Ghosh that the State professing to be a welfare state cannot claim to have perfected its titled over a piece of land by invoking the doctrine of adverse possession to grab the property of its own citizens.
Anita Aggarwal v/s H.P. that Section 102 CrPC (Power of police officer to seize certain property) empowers the police officer to seize certain property on existence of a condition that the said property should have been alleged or suspected to have been stolen or which may be found under circumstances
Mohammad Sultan Nagoo vs Custodian Evacuee Property that the government has a responsibility to safeguard, maintain and effectively utilize evacuee properties.
L & T Finance Limited v Maharashtra that pendency of secured creditors applications for possession of secured assets is bad for financial health of the country.
Government of Kerala vs Joseph that merely a long period of possession, does not translate into the right of adverse possession.
Kannaian Naidu v Kamsala Ammal that a wife, who contributed to the acquisition of family assets by performing the household chores would be entitled to an equal share in the properties as she had indirectly contributed to its purchase.
Brij Narayan Shukla vs Sudesh Kumar Alias Suresh Kumar Allahabad High Court that had allowed a suit for claiming rights by adverse possession and held that ownership and possession of land cannot be claimed through permissive possession arising from tenancy.
Revanasiddappa vs Mallikarjun the exercise of its civil appellate jurisdiction has granted legitimacy and property rights to the children of void or voidable marriages in Hindu joint families.
Top